Gravely Speaking

Springdale Cemetery, Madison, Indiana

Dr. Joseph Barnard (1838-1926) was a Presbyterian minister who plied his craft in Pennsylvania, Iowa, Wisconsin, and Illinois. Joseph and his wife Martha Grey Grubb Barnard (1842-1919) and their children eventually settled in Madison, Indiana, where Barnard served as a minister of the 2^nd Presbyterian Church there for over 20 years.

The Birth, by George Grey Barnard

While Barnard was an influential minister in southern Indiana, his son, George Grey Barnard, (1863-1938) gained fame as a noted American sculptor. His works can be found in New York at the Metropolitan Museum of Art, the town of Cairo, Illinois, the state capitol building at Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, among other places, as well as, the Springdale Cemetery at Madison, Indiana, where he sculpted a statue to honor his parents.

Some sources say the statue was titled, “Let There Be Light” while John Bower’s book, Guardians of the Soul, a book about cemetery sculptures in Indiana, say it was titled “Immortality.” According to the book Barnard’s masterful sculpture was described as “an incomparably beautiful figure of a woman in the matching loveliness of mature perfection and form…the lovely hands are uplifted, parting the veil that encircles the voiceless silence of dreamless dust.”

Elmwood Cemetery, Charlotte, North Carolina

Erected by the

members of

JOHN ROBINSON’S CIRCUS

In memory of

JOHN KING

killed at Charlotte

N.C. September 27, 1880

by the

elephant CHIEF

May his soul rest in peace

The death of animal trainer, John King, is a tragedy that was recounted in many different places. In the book, It Happened in North Carolina, by Scott Kent, the elephant Chief became murderous because of surging levels of testosterone which increase dramatically in the male elephant once a year in a period called musth.

However, the best way to describe the tragedy that took place at the circus is to quote from the Washington Post, Sunday March 3, 1907—27 years after the event. The New Orleans Picayune interviewed Ed Cullen, who had been in the employ of the John Robinson Circus when an elephant named Chief went on a rampage as the following excerpt that the Post ran carrying the Picayune article in all of its lurid and salacious detail:

“Our elephant trainer was a young man named King, thoroughly up to his business and acquainted with all wild animals as few men ever get to be. King loved his charges, and his charges loved him, that is all of them but Chief, and as for Mary, she was just crazy about the man, and would trumpet with delight whenever she saw him approaching.

“Mary was far bigger than Chief, and her weight and power gave her the right to shine in the role of the wife who wears the trousers, but for all Mary’s Amazonian tendencies she was not a flirt, and gave Chief no cause for jealousy. But Chief early took a dislike to King, the trainer, for no other reason, I believe, than that Mary showed great affection for the man, and there were times that if King ever came near Chief the elephant would give unmistakable signs of anger and a dangerous gleam would show in his mean little eyes.

“Once Chief lashed out at King with his trunk when the trainer was sweeping Mary’s sides with a broom, and the swing of the blow just missed the man. King jumped to one side, and as he did so Mary, with a bellow of rage, smashed the smaller elephant a blow on the head with her trunk that brought Chief to his knees. Mary was ready for a charge, her big head lowered to serve as a battering—ram, and Chief would have fared badly that had not King acted promptly. He knew that he could trust Mary. And, springing in front of the big beast, extended both his arms, and cried: ‘Get back, girl: there now!’ His order was obeyed, and Mary, wheeling around, went off quietly to her place, and so a panic in the elephant house was averted.

“Our show was in North Carolina, near Charlotte, when the grim tragedy I am going to tell you of happened. We had been playing a number of little towns with some success, and instead of traveling on the railroads, used our elephants and horses to move the animals and tent wagons from place to place over the hard country roads.

“Mary at this game was of more service to us than a dozen horses or an army of men. She would lead the elephants up and they were all too much afraid of that ever-steady trunk of hers not to follow when she trumpeted the command, and the hulking beasts would shove wagons out of ruts, carry tent poles in their trunks, or do any other manual labor we had for them.

“Chief had been acting very mean, and it was up to Mary to punish him several times before we reached Charlotte, but for all the chastisement he received from his massive wife, the elephant seemed bent on mischief. Indeed, as we afterward found out, the blather was showing on his right temple.

“Let me explain myself, as perhaps few of you are familiar enough with elephants to know what I mean by the blister. Elephants—that is, some elephants, and Chief was included in that class—have periods of madness, but nature has provided the means by which man may anticipate that period, and put the beasts in restraint. The periods are more violent in some elephants than in others, and while in one the mood might reach complete madness, in the majority it only assumes the proportions of marked ill-temper and surliness. You’ve often seen elephants in the circus chained by the leg to a heavy peg, no doubt? Well, they are the surly ones; the keepers tell you they are mankillers, naturally vicious and such rot; that’s only stock talk; the blister has shown on the animals, and they are kept in temporary restraint until the crazy period passes. A week or two before the elephant enters the mean state a swelling, hardly larger than a silver quarter, forms on his temple. The swelling gradually increases in size of a large hickory nut. The experienced showman has the elephant chained by the leg or well hobbled with chains, if the outfit is moving, the minute the swelling shows.

Now, after all this explanation, which is perhaps dry enough, let me get back to my story. The blister was on Chief’s right temple when our show pulled into Charlotte for a one-night stand, but King had not noticed the swelling, so he was off his guard. Chief cut up badly when the Hindoos came to put his howdah on for the grand march, and even when Mary was walked up to bring him to account, he showed a disposition to still be unruly, and appeared willing to fight the queen of the herd. His temper was such that he was left out in the animal tent, only Mary and the other elephants—six in number went on in the entry.

“The show passed without incident, and as we could not move over the roads in the dark, we waited until daylight to break camp. With the first light of day, the canvas was down, folded, and on the wagons; the poles were lying piled, and the horses were being harnessed to the cages. King got his elephants in marching order, and followed in the wake of the moving vans, and all went well until the heavy cage in which were confined the four lions stuck fast in the muddy road, a short distance from town. The six horses drawing the cage strained and pulled to no purpose, and as a last resort King was called up and asked to bring one of his elephants.

“King went away and returned in a few minutes with Mary and Chief. Whatever possessed him to bring that mean bull elephant I don’t know; his choice, poor fellow, cost him his life. King spoke to Chief and ordered him forward, and the elephant obeyed, although unwillingly, and as he stepped into the mud, he swung his trunk dangerously from side to side. No amount of prodding with the driver’s hook would prevail on Chief to put his head to the cage, and King, thinking the elephant was frightened or disconcerted by the rumbling roars which came from the imprisoned lions, stepped into the mud and leaned against the van, and made as though shoving.

“Crushed King to Jelly

“Chief’s time had come; he saw the one great chance to fill his cup of vengeance, and turning suddenly strike the cage. The elephant’s bulk crushed into King and jammed him against the cage, and the great beast, throwing all his weight into the effort, smashed that unfortunate trainer as flat as a pancake—pardon the term, but it is the only fitting one I can find. Every bone in King’s body was crushed into a bloody pulp, with what few features that were distinguishable flattened out and twisted as though a stone grinder had passed over them.

“With the act of murder the mad mood claimed Chief entirely, and throwing his great trunk into the air and trumpeting shrilly he dashed wildly down the road, overturning several horses that were in his way.

According to the Charlotte Observer , September 28, 1880, “and the elephant turned and started up the railroad track, the excited crowd fleeing in every direction. The loose elephant got into the main streets of the city, and a crowd was being formed to hunt him down and shoot him when it was learned that the circus people were after the truant beast. “They took the other two elephants, Mary and The Boy, and, driving them rapidly through the streets, overtook The Chief, chained him to the others and finally got him back to the circus grounds.”

John King lingered through the night of the tragedy and died at 11:00 the next morning on September 28^th. He was promptly buried that same afternoon. A hearse carried his body drawn by four white circus horses. Mary and the Boy followed his casket.

John King was buried in the Elmwood Cemetery at Charlotte, North Carolina, beneath a five-foot monument donated by his fellow circus workers. On it is carved the image of an elephant and a palm tree carved by the Confederate veteran Billy Berryhill.

But, that was not the end of the story for the now infamous elephant named Chief. The circus masters decided that Chief was too much for them to handle, so they shipped him to Cincinnati to the Zoological Gardens. Chief remained rogue and reportedly killed two more trainers before he met his fate and was killed.

The January 4, 1891, New York Times published a snippet about what became of, at least part of Chief. “Roast Loin of Elephant From the Hotel Mail, Dec. 27. On the bill of fare of the Palace, Cincinnati, one day last week there appeared the rather unusual dainty, “loin of elephant.” It was, in fact, a part of Chief, the vicious elephant who was shot in the Cincinnati Zoological Garden, and was not bad eating, as some of the force of this office can testify. It was without exception the best roast elephant that any of us had ever tasted.”

And that still was not the last of Chief.

According to the University of Cincinnati magazine, “Certainly you would have thought your eyes were deceiving you, but a full-size stuffed elephant was, indeed, transported on a horse-drawn cart outside the UC gymnasium in 1902. More surprising, the pachyderm lived on campus until 1998.

Old Chief, a five-ton Asian elephant, was imported to the U.S. in 1872 and performed with the Cincinnati-based Robinson Circus until his demise in 1890. His remains were stuffed and displayed at the Cincinnati Zoo for a decade or so until making the trip to UC.

The skin and stuffing somehow disappeared, but the skeleton stayed on campus until a grant allowed UC to transfer its collection of paleontological specimens — including the behemoth’s bones — to the Cincinnati Museum Center.”

Crown Hill Cemetery, Salem, Indiana

John Naugle was a master carver who plied his trade in the Salem, Indiana, area. Examples of his work can be found in the Crown Hill Cemetery of Salem. Two examples, the Lula McMahan monument and the Emmanuel Zink Monument, demonstrate his talent as a carver. In these examples shown here, Naugle crafted towering monuments that are architectural in nature. They resemble each other in form, but have minor changes in detail and symbolism.

Crown Hill Cemetery, Salem, Indiana

According to all reports he loved his craft and was widely recognized for his talent. But, according to Guardians of the Soul, a book about cemetery sculptures in Indiana by John Bower, one of his greatest joys was at the end of the day when he was met by his four-year old daughter, Caddy, at their garden gate. Tragedy struck when illness befell the little girl and she died a few days later. John Naugle was bereft and unable concentrate at his job and many projects were left undone. According to Bower’s book, “many of his duties were taken over by an itinerant stone mason who just happened to be passing through town.”

Crown Hill Cemetery, Salem, Indiana

Not only did this stone carver complete many of the projects that were languishing in the Naugle’s workshop, but he also produced a memorial to Caddy, appropriately, standing at the garden gate, as if she were still waiting for her father. By all accounts, he then disappeared almost as if he had been a ghost.